Lords of the Round Table

9th December 2014

“We have heard in today’s important debate that noble Lords want dialogue and discussion with the noble Lord, Lord Saatchi, and indeed he has said that himself. Is he prepared to consider hosting a round-table discussion with all those Peers who have an interest in the matters before us today? That would be a very helpful way forward.”
Baroness Wheeler, Medical Innovation Bill Committee Stage, 24th October 2014

Lord Saatchi’s colleagues, perhaps frustrated by his rejection of almost all their proposed amendments to his Medical Innovation Bill (the Saatchi Bill) and his dismissal of their concerns about its manifest dangers, pressed him to host a round-table discussion to air the problems they saw with this bill.

On 20th November, the official Twitter feed of the Bill confirmed the discussion had taken place.


Unfortunately, there is no published record of who was invited, who attended, or what was said.

Lord Saatchi, since he claims to listen to all views and to want an open discussion of the issues, really ought to regard the round table meeting as an open part of the democratic process. Given that the meeting was requested by his noble colleagues in the Committee stage of the House of Lords, we ought to be able to know about what went on in the meeting. We have been able to watch every other stage streamed live on the internet, and been able to read transcripts of every word spoken. But the round table meeting is thus far a closed book.

This matters. Lord Saatchi has been accused, with justification, of failing to note criticism and of ignoring advice, from a vast range of medical and legal organisations, patient groups and charities. He didn’t wait for the results of the official Department of Health consultation before steering the bill through the Lords, and when those results did appear he ignored those too.

If it were to turn out that the attendees at the round table meeting were not representative of the vast range of expert opposition to the bill, then Lord Saatchi could be said to be just paying lip service to the discussion his colleagues urged him to have, and thereby to be undermining the democratic process.

I have asked the Saatchi Bill official Twitter feed three times to say who attended. I have also e-mailed Dominic Nutt – the bill’s Campaign Director – and asked for details. I have not had a reply to any of these overtures.

I hope that this is merely an unfortunate (repeated) oversight on their part, and that they will provide a full invitees list, attendees list, and transcript at the earliest opportunity.


More Saatchi Bill articles

The Saatchi Bill



Contact me here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: